Costume Quest Play Order poster
Games Completed 2010-2014

Costume Quest Play Order

Both Costume Quest games plus the Grubbins on Ice DLC in release order, from the October 2010 Halloween debut through Costume Quest 2 in October 2014. Release order carries the Reynold and Wren sibling story straight through with no third game announced.

Last updated October 5, 2026

Play Order

0 / 3 played

Original, DLC, then sequel.

About Costume Quest

Costume Quest is a Double Fine Halloween RPG where kids in costumes transform into giants in turn battles. The original arrived October 19, 2010. Grubbins on Ice added a winter DLC chapter December 21, 2010.

Costume Quest 2 followed October 7, 2014 with time travel to stop Dr. Orel White. Double Fine said in August 2025 it works only on original IPs with no sequels planned, so no third game fits. Play the original, then the DLC, then the sequel in release order. The turn battles stay light and quick.

Good to know

Release order equals story order closely enough that one list covers it. The DLC sits after the original campaign and before the sequel in both release and story. New players can skip the DLC without losing the sequel setup, but it is short and seasonal. Treat the series as finished at Costume Quest 2 in 2014 until Double Fine announces otherwise.